A limited-risk distributor has incurred operating losses for three consecutive years, whilst the group's principal remains profitable.
Would you consider the losses sufficient grounds to challenge the existing functional characterisation? Under what circumstances would you expec
A limited-risk distributor has incurred operating losses for three consecutive years, whilst the group's principal remains profitable.
Would you consider the losses sufficient grounds to challenge the existing functional characterisation? Under what circumstances would you expec
An AI agent performs a benchmarking analysis and selects 15 comparable companies. A transfer pricing practitioner independently performs the same exercise and selects 11. Only seven companies appear in both sets.
Both have applied the same screening criteria and both present tec
A multinational relocates its senior decision-makers from London to Amsterdam. Its operational functions, assets, workforce and commercial strategy remain unchanged.
Would you reconsider the existing transfer pricing method? Would the relocation alone provide sufficient grounds
A multinational applies a uniform 5% mark-up to its intra-group management services, which include accounting, HR, strategic planning and senior executive oversight.
Would you be comfortable defending the entire management charge under the OECD's simplified approach?
Would you
Two advisory firms prepare Local Files of equal quality. One takes 40 hours to complete the work; the other takes eight hours using AI.
Should the second firm charge less? Is the client purchasing the adviser's time, technical expertise or the outcome?
A German manufacturing business seconds five experienced engineers to its Polish subsidiary for two years. By the time they return to Germany, the Polish workforce can independently operate and adapt a proprietary manufacturing process.
Has the German entity provided a service,
Two junior practitioners join a transfer pricing team. Both receive the same training in benchmarking methodology. One spends six months performing benchmarking analyses manually. The other uses AI to complete the same work in considerably less time, creating capacity to work on
A practitioner conducts a functional interview in 2026 to document transactions undertaken in 2023. Several key decision-makers have since left the business.
What would you consider sufficient evidence to establish the historical functional profile?
A parent company provides an explicit guarantee for its subsidiary's external borrowing. However, the subsidiary would have obtained the same interest rate without the guarantee.
Would you consider a guarantee fee appropriate? Does the assumption of additional risk by the parent
A UK subsidiary has a standalone borrowing capacity of £50 million. Its membership of a financially strong multinational group means that an independent bank would be willing to lend it £80 million without an explicit guarantee.
Under the revised UK transfer pricing rules, would
A subsidiary enters into a ten-year fixed-rate intercompany loan at 6%. Three years later, market interest rates have fallen considerably.
Would you expect the subsidiary to renegotiate its financing arrangements, taking into account the options realistically available to both p
A UK subsidiary entered into a ten-year fixed-rate intercompany loan in 2023 at an interest rate of 7%, established without taking implicit support into account.
Applying the revised UK transfer pricing legislation, an analysis reflecting implicit support suggests an arm's lengt