A multinational applies a uniform 5% mark-up to its intra-group management services, which include accounting, HR, strategic planning and senior executive oversight.
Would you be comfortable defending the entire management charge under the OECD's simplified approach?
Would you segregate the services and benchmark them separately, or could a uniform 5% mark-up still be commercially defensible?
I would approach this from a risk and materiality perspective, taking into account the quantum of the transaction, the composition of the management charge and the jurisdictions involved.
How material is the potential adjustment, and how likely are the respective tax authorities to challenge the existing arrangement?
There is a balance to be struck between technical precision, the cost of undertaking separate benchmarking exercises and the administrative burden of maintaining multiple pricing arrangements.