Read

THE TP LADYEDIT

What I’ve been thinking about.

The TP Lady Edit13 Nov 2026

When does sharing expertise become a transfer of know-how?

Knowledge is a rather peculiar asset. You can give it away without losing it, although you may well lose some of the economic advantage that came with being the only one who had it. From a transfer pricing perspective, this makes sharing expertise between group entities particularly interesting.

Know-how has a tendency to reside in people rather than neatly within the entities to which we have attributed its economic value. People move, teach others, acquire new expertise and occasionally leave. Intercompany agreements tend to be rather more stationary.

The scientist and philosopher Michael Polanyi explored something particularly relevant to this discussion in his work on tacit knowledge: the idea that much of what we know is difficult to articulate. An experienced engineer may be capable of identifying a manufacturing defect without being able to explain precisely how they arrived at that conclusion. Much of the commercial value of their expertise lies in years of accumulated experience, rather than in anything that could readily be documented in an operating manual.

This presents an interesting difficulty for transfer pricing. We spend considerable time establishing where intellectual property is legally owned, yet some of the capabilities through which that intellectual property derives its commercial value may be rather less geographically settled.

Consider a multinational manufacturing business that seconds several experienced engineers to a newly established overseas subsidiary. Over the course of two years, the local workforce becomes proficient in a manufacturing process, learns to identify production inefficiencies and develops the ability to adapt the process to different operating conditions. The engineers eventually return home.

What remains behind?

Paragraph 1.175 of the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines addresses precisely this possibility. Whilst the secondment of employees does not ordinarily give rise to separate compensation beyond the services performed, the OECD recognises that certain secondments may also make valuable proprietary knowledge available to another group entity.

The distinction deserves some attention. An employee acquiring professional experience does not necessarily mean that an intangible has been transferred. Nor does an improvement in the capabilities of a local workforce automatically establish that it has acquired proprietary know-how. Much depends on the nature of the knowledge, the rights associated with its use and the circumstances under which it became available.

I find the implications for DEMPE analyses particularly interesting. A functional analysis undertaken at the inception of a business arrangement may accurately reflect where the expertise was concentrated at the time. Repeat the exercise five years later and one may discover that the individuals responsible for developing and enhancing the original technology are no longer exclusively based within the same entity. The recipient of the technology may have become a contributor to its subsequent development.

There are two potentially distinct economic events here: the original provision of proprietary knowledge and the subsequent contributions made by those who received it. Both warrant examination in their own right, without assuming that legal ownership has changed or that an entitlement to residual profits automatically follows.

Artificial intelligence introduces a further dimension. Businesses are increasingly interested in capturing the accumulated expertise of their employees in proprietary knowledge systems, analytical tools and AI agents. Knowledge that was previously difficult to communicate, let alone reproduce at scale, may become more readily accessible across an organisation.

I wonder whether, in attempting to retain institutional knowledge through technology, some businesses will inadvertently make its cross-border dissemination considerably easier.

Perhaps one of the more interesting questions to ask during a functional interview is what the business can do today that it could not do when its transfer pricing policy was first established.

The answer may have very little to do with what appears on its organisational chart.

That TP Lady.

All views expressed are my own. This article does not constitute tax advice.

Sources

  1. OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines (2022), Chapter I, paragraphs 1.172–1.176, and Chapter VI, Section B.
  2. Michael Polanyi, The Tacit Dimension (1966).