Is the UK becoming a profit split printing press?
One of the more interesting discussions at the IFA/HMRC/HMT Annual Conference concerned the geographical location of decision-makers. How much can we infer about the appropriate transfer pricing method from where senior individuals happen to sit? And at what point does their involvement justify an entitlement to residual profits?
Even when we agree that a profit split is appropriate, we are left with the rather more interesting question of how independent enterprises might have divided those profits. The relative salaries of their employees may be readily ascertainable. Whether they tell us anything meaningful about the relative economic value of their contributions is another matter.
Consider two pharmaceutical companies collaborating on the development of a drug. One contributes years of research and proprietary technology; the other brings clinical development expertise and access to established distribution networks. In negotiating the commercial terms of their collaboration, I suspect neither would be particularly interested in the other's payroll figures in isolation. They would, however, be interested in the availability of alternative commercial partners, the probability of regulatory approval, the capital at risk and the commercial opportunities to which the collaboration gives them access.
In transfer pricing, we attempt to reconstruct some of that negotiation between entities that have never had to negotiate with one another as independent parties.
Paragraph 2.166 of the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines is worth revisiting in this context. The OECD places considerable emphasis on the economic validity of the allocation basis and deliberately avoids prescribing a universal set of splitting factors. Understandably so. Expenditure on research and development may provide a reasonable proxy for relative contributions in one industry and a remarkably poor one in another. Even within the same industry, the relationship between expenditure and value creation is unlikely to be linear.
Consider, for instance, a technology business with engineering teams in London and Warsaw. A profit split based on employee remuneration, without appropriate consideration of geographical differences in remuneration levels, could attribute considerably more value to the London team. Would relocating the London engineers to Warsaw, without changing their responsibilities or the quality of their work, alter their economic contribution? It would certainly alter the spreadsheet.
There is also the question of time. An intangible developed ten years ago may continue to generate substantial profits long after the expenditure associated with its development has diminished. Conversely, a business may be investing considerable sums in developing technology that will never become commercially viable. Annual expenditure tells us relatively little about either outcome unless we understand the economics behind it.
The location of decision-makers presents a similar difficulty. The ability to control economically significant risks deserves appropriate recognition, but the fact that an individual exercises such control does not, in itself, establish the appropriate method of remuneration, let alone the proportion of residual profits attributable to the entity within which that individual operates.
I also wonder how comfortable businesses and tax authorities would be applying their preferred splitting factors in considerably less profitable years. Where the accurate delineation of a transaction supports the sharing of actual profits and losses, the economic rationale behind the allocation should be capable of surviving both outcomes. An allocation key becomes particularly interesting when the number it is allocating turns negative.
HMRC's own guidance at INTM421070 makes reference to the relative bargaining positions of the parties in the context of a residual profit split. I find this particularly relevant because bargaining power does not necessarily correspond to the relative cost of performing a function. An enterprise may make a relatively inexpensive contribution that is difficult to substitute and without which the commercial arrangement would make very little sense.
Whether the UK is becoming a profit split printing press remains an open question. What interests me rather more is the possibility that, in attempting to move away from the limitations of conventional benchmarking, we may become disproportionately reliant on another set of readily available numbers.
Spurious precision is considerably easier to achieve when both sides of the equation are in Excel.
That TP Lady.
All views expressed are my own. This article does not constitute tax advice.
Sources
- OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines (2022), Chapter II, particularly paragraphs 2.125–2.145 and 2.166–2.178.
- HMRC International Manual, INTM421070, Profit split.
- HMRC International Manual, INTM484070, OECD methods.
