Intangibles stole the show.
If an entity uses proprietary know-how to provide a service, is it possible that it has also transferred that know-how? It is a question I found myself returning to during the OECD public consultation on intra-group services, particularly following the IFA discussion on royalties and intangibles.
We devote considerable effort to categorising intercompany transactions, whilst businesses seem to devote remarkably little effort to conducting their affairs in accordance with those categories. The distinction between services and intangibles is a particularly interesting example.
The OECD's proposed revisions to Chapter VII, published in June 2026, dedicate an entire section to services provided in connection with other transactions. Paragraph 7.41 is particularly worth reading. It considers the possibility that strategic advisory services provided following an acquisition may also result in a transfer of proprietary know-how.
I find the implications for post-acquisition integration particularly interesting. A multinational acquires a business and spends the following eighteen months teaching its new subsidiaries how to operate. It introduces proprietary pricing methodologies, commercial frameworks and risk assessment capabilities. Eventually, the newly acquired businesses become sufficiently proficient to operate without the same degree of assistance from the parent. Throughout this period, the arrangement may have been documented and remunerated as a management service.
What, economically, has the parent provided?
There is already provision for much of this in Chapter VI of the existing OECD Guidelines. Paragraphs 6.98 and 6.104 contemplate two quite different circumstances: the transfer of an intangible alongside a service and the use of an intangible in performing a service without transferring any rights in it. Both may have significant pricing implications, although the nature of the underlying transactions differs.
Consider a group that has developed proprietary software for forecasting commodity prices. Its central team uses the software to produce market forecasts for other group entities. Compare this with an arrangement under which the subsidiaries obtain access to the software and the rights necessary to operate it themselves. Both arrangements may serve the same commercial objective, yet what the recipients acquire differs considerably.
There is a further complication. Even where no intangible has been transferred, its use in providing a service may render an otherwise sensible benchmarking exercise unreliable. Example 18 of the OECD consultation draft illustrates this problem in the context of a construction group whose parent provides technical services drawing on valuable proprietary IP. The apparent functional similarity between the parent and independent service providers is insufficient to establish comparability.
Equally, the identification of an intangible does not automatically warrant a separate royalty. Independent businesses regularly pay for arrangements comprising several economically interdependent elements through a single commercial charge. Artificially separating those elements for transfer pricing purposes may introduce precisely the sort of distortion the analysis was intended to eliminate.
I suspect artificial intelligence will make these distinctions considerably more interesting. As businesses develop proprietary agents, analytical frameworks and automated decision-making capabilities, the internal provision of services may increasingly involve access to technology developed elsewhere in the group. Whether an entity is providing an output, granting access to a capability or transferring the capability itself could become a fairly consequential question.
There is some irony in revisiting the guidance on intra-group services at a time when the nature of a service is itself becoming increasingly difficult to define.
I wonder how many intercompany services agreements will outlive the commercial arrangements they were originally drafted to describe.
That TP Lady.
All views expressed are my own. This article does not constitute tax advice.
Sources
- OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines (2022), Chapter VI, paragraphs 6.10, 6.98, 6.104 and 6.203–6.205.
- OECD Public Consultation: Revisions to Chapter VII, June 2026, Section B.3, paragraph 7.41 and Annex I, Example 18.
- OECD Public Consultation Meeting, 9 November 2026.
