What should a transfer pricing team stop doing?
Much of the discussion around artificial intelligence concerns what businesses will be able to do in the future. I find the question of what they should cease doing equally interesting.
Transfer pricing functions tend to accumulate responsibilities over time. A new regulatory requirement introduces an additional reporting process. An acquisition brings another set of intercompany arrangements. A historical tax enquiry results in additional layers of internal review. Rarely does any of this prompt a corresponding discussion about which existing activities might no longer be necessary.
The result is often a function whose operational architecture reflects the history of the business rather than its current needs.
Consider a multinational that undertakes an annual review of its intercompany services arrangements. Over the years, several teams have become involved in collecting, reconciling and reviewing substantially the same financial information. Before investing in technology to accelerate these activities, it might be worth establishing why each of them exists in the first place.
Automating an inefficient process may simply make inefficiency less expensive.
I suspect that one of the more difficult responsibilities of a Senior TP Manager is deciding where the organisation can afford to devote less attention. This requires a sufficiently sophisticated understanding of materiality, regulatory obligations and commercial exposure to distinguish between activities that manage genuine risks and those that provide a rather comfortable sense of administrative diligence.
There are also implications for the professional development of the team. If automation releases a considerable proportion of its capacity, how should that capacity be redeployed? There may be opportunities to become more involved in commercial decision-making, develop sector-specific expertise or examine the economic assumptions underpinning existing transfer pricing policies.
These activities may ultimately contribute more to the business than further refinements to its reporting processes.
I would find it interesting to conduct an annual review of a transfer pricing function in which every recurring activity had to justify its continued existence. Mandatory obligations would remain, of course, although the manner in which they are fulfilled need not be immune from scrutiny.
Perhaps the most valuable outcome of introducing artificial intelligence into a transfer pricing function will be the opportunity to reconsider what we expect that function to do.
A little organisational subtraction might be overdue.
That TP Lady.
Sources
No public source references supplied.
