In-house

Grow

Grow · In-house · TP Manager17 Nov 2026

The art of managing external advisers.

Commissioning good transfer pricing advice requires a surprising amount of expertise on the part of the person commissioning it. Knowing which questions to outsource is arguably as important as knowing whom to instruct.

Having worked in advisory, I find the relationship between external advisers and in-house tax professionals particularly interesting. The adviser may have considerable technical expertise, exposure to different industries and an appreciation of how other multinational businesses have approached similar problems. The in-house professional possesses something rather difficult to acquire over the course of an engagement: institutional knowledge.

The quality of the advice depends substantially on how effectively these two perspectives come together.

Consider a business commissioning a review of its intercompany financing arrangements. An external adviser may be perfectly capable of assessing borrowing capacity and benchmarking interest rates. Understanding the group's broader financing strategy, its relationship with external lenders and the commercial rationale behind its treasury decisions requires considerable input from within the business.

I suspect that some of the most valuable contributions an in-house transfer pricing manager makes occur before an engagement letter has even been signed. Defining the question, identifying the relevant stakeholders and establishing what the business intends to achieve can fundamentally influence the quality and economics of the engagement.

There is also merit in distinguishing between purchasing technical expertise and purchasing additional capacity. The commercial rationale for outsourcing differs considerably between the two, as should the criteria against which external advisers are selected and their performance assessed.

I would also be interested in how systematically businesses retain the knowledge generated through external advisory engagements. A technically sophisticated report may have considerable immediate value, but its longer-term usefulness diminishes if nobody within the organisation understands the assumptions on which it was prepared.

Artificial intelligence will make the economics of these relationships particularly interesting. As certain analytical and research capabilities become more accessible internally, transfer pricing managers may find themselves reconsidering which activities warrant external expenditure and where independent professional judgement remains particularly valuable.

Perhaps one of the more useful questions to ask at the conclusion of an advisory engagement is what the organisation now knows that it did not know before.

Ideally, it should have acquired something more enduring than another PDF.

That TP Lady.

Sources

No public source references supplied.