On developing professional judgement.
One of the more uncomfortable stages of professional development is when people stop telling you what to do and start asking you what you think. Particularly when you have spent the preceding few years becoming rather good at following instructions.
Transfer pricing offers considerable scope for professional disagreement. Two perfectly competent practitioners, working with the same information and consulting the same OECD Guidelines, may arrive at different conclusions. Understanding why is an important part of becoming a more independent practitioner.
Consider an intercompany financing arrangement. The financial projections suggest that the borrower has sufficient borrowing capacity, although the business operates in a particularly volatile industry. There are several reasonable approaches to assessing its creditworthiness, each involving assumptions that could materially influence the outcome of the analysis. At some point, somebody has to decide which assumptions are commercially defensible.
The spreadsheet is unlikely to volunteer an opinion.
Developing professional judgement requires becoming comfortable with the possibility that further research may complicate a question rather than resolve it. There is rarely a point at which all the relevant information becomes available and the appropriate course of action presents itself.
I also think there is considerable merit in developing an appreciation of what matters. A relatively minor inconsistency in a benchmarking analysis may warrant less attention than an untested assumption underpinning the entire transfer pricing policy. Both deserve consideration, although perhaps not an equal proportion of the engagement budget.
The ability to distinguish between the two becomes increasingly important as one assumes responsibility for reviewing other people's work.
One exercise worth undertaking before approaching a more senior colleague is to formulate your own view of the matter. Consider what you would recommend, what evidence supports your recommendation and what additional information might persuade you otherwise.
There is nothing particularly embarrassing about changing your mind in light of a better argument. Being unable to explain why you held your original position is arguably more concerning.
Artificial intelligence introduces an interesting dimension to professional judgement. Access to plausible interpretations of technical guidance is becoming increasingly inexpensive. The ability to assess their merits, identify their limitations and recognise their commercial implications may consequently become more valuable.
I suspect that a considerable part of one's professional reputation is established during those years when one begins to exercise judgement but still has the benefit of somebody else's oversight.
It seems a particularly good time to develop opinions, invite disagreement and become accustomed to occasionally being wrong.
That TP Lady.
Sources
No public source references supplied.
