In practice

Grow

Grow · In practice · Associate17 Nov 2026

The art of asking another question.

One of the more useful skills I developed early in my career was recognising when I had understood enough to complete a piece of work but not enough to explain it. Unfortunately, the two can be surprisingly easy to confuse.

Transfer pricing is a rather accommodating discipline in this respect. It is entirely possible to prepare a benchmarking analysis, populate a functional analysis and produce a reasonably sophisticated-looking report without fully understanding the commercial arrangement one is attempting to price.

Consider a relatively straightforward distribution arrangement. You have established that the local entity is a limited-risk distributor, selected the TNMM and identified a set of comparable companies. The analysis appears perfectly sensible. But what happens if the local entity makes a loss? Who decides which products it sells? Who bears the economic consequences of unsold inventory? And why has the business chosen to organise itself in this particular way?

The answers may make you considerably less comfortable with the analysis you have just completed. That is generally a useful development.

There is a tendency early in one's career to regard technical knowledge as the principal measure of professional competence. Understandably so. There is an enormous amount to learn, and the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines are hardly light reading. However, knowing which paragraph to consult is a different skill from recognising the circumstances in which it becomes relevant.

I find that some of the most valuable learning opportunities occur when reviewing somebody else's work. Why did they reject a particular comparable? Why did they spend three paragraphs explaining something that could apparently have been explained in one sentence? Why did they ask a question during a functional interview that seemed entirely unrelated to the transaction under consideration?

Understanding the reasoning behind these decisions is arguably more valuable than becoming proficient at reproducing their outputs.

Artificial intelligence makes this particularly relevant to those entering the profession today. A junior practitioner can now produce in minutes something that might previously have occupied an entire afternoon. What concerns me is how much of the intellectual development associated with that afternoon we might inadvertently dispense with.

I would encourage anyone beginning their career in transfer pricing to occasionally ask an AI model to explain the assumptions behind its answer, and then spend some time trying to establish whether those assumptions are defensible. The same exercise works remarkably well with a spreadsheet, an intercompany agreement and, occasionally, a more senior colleague.

There is no particular merit in asking questions for the sake of being seen to ask them. Genuine curiosity tends to reveal itself in the quality of the second question, once the first has been answered.

It is a habit worth developing before people start expecting you to have all the answers.

That TP Lady.

Sources

No public source references supplied.