Loss-Making Distributor Diagnostic
Decompose the loss and test it against the accurately delineated arrangement, not the 'limited-risk' label.
For external testing with synthetic inputs only. Do not enter confidential data. Verify outputs independently.
Required inputs (used externally only)
- distribution agreement
- transfer pricing policy
- Local File
- functional analysis
- benchmark study
- trial balances
- statutory accounts
- segmented accounts
- budgets and forecasts
- product-level results
- customer and channel data
- inventory reports
- marketing plans
- market data
- internal correspondence
- restructuring papers
Expected deliverables
- Multi-year financial analysis
- Quantified loss bridge
- Risk-by-risk control analysis
- Agreement-versus-conduct assessment
- Independent-party options analysis
- Evidence supporting the loss
- Evidence undermining the position
- Potential pricing or compensation scenarios
- Strongest taxpayer argument
- Strongest likely tax authority challenge
- Recommended evidence-gathering plan
- Draft factual defence narrative
Prompt
For external testing with synthetic inputs only. Do not enter confidential data. Verify outputs independently.
- Role
- Inputs
- Variables
- Task
- Output
- Comment
- Prompt text
Act as an experienced transfer pricing specialist reviewing the losses incurred by [DISTRIBUTOR] in [JURISDICTION] during [PERIOD].Determine whether the losses are consistent with the accurately delineated distribution arrangement, whether particular risks materialised and whether the existing pricing remains supportable.Do not assume that an entity described as a "limited-risk distributor" must earn a positive return in every period.MATERIAL PROVIDEDI may provide:- distribution agreement;- transfer pricing policy;- Local File;- functional analysis;- benchmark study;- trial balances;- statutory accounts;- segmented accounts;- budgets and forecasts;- product-level results;- customer and channel data;- inventory reports;- marketing plans;- market data;- internal correspondence;- restructuring papers.CONTROLS1. The label "limited-risk distributor" is not evidence.2. Determine which risks were:- contractually assumed;- controlled in practice;- financially borne;- actually realised.3. Do not attribute the loss to "market conditions" without identifying:- the precise market event;- its timing;- its financial effect;- the entity controlling the relevant response;- supporting evidence.4. Do not use hindsight to rewrite the ex-ante risk allocation.5. Do not assume that another group entity must compensate the distributor. Test what independent parties might reasonably have agreed.6. Separate operating underperformance from incorrect transfer pricing implementation.LOSS DECOMPOSITIONQuantify, where reliable data permits:- market contraction;- start-up activity;- market penetration;- product launch;- product failure;- inventory obsolescence;- supply disruption;- customer default;- foreign exchange;- regulatory change;- price controls;- local operating inefficiency;- group-directed expenditure;- restructuring costs;- accounting errors;- incorrect transfer pricing implementation.For each material loss driver answer:1. When was the exposure identified?2. Was it anticipated when the arrangement was agreed?3. Which party contractually assumed it?4. Who made the relevant decisions?5. Who monitored the exposure?6. Who determined mitigation action?7. Could the distributor avoid or reduce the exposure?8. Who had financial capacity?9. Who expected to receive the corresponding upside?10. What happened when the downside materialised?11. What contemporaneous evidence supports the answer?INDEPENDENT-PARTY ANALYSISConsider whether an independent distributor might have:- accepted the loss;- negotiated a lower purchase price;- requested marketing support;- sought an indemnity;- reduced inventory;- changed its territory;- revised contractual terms;- terminated the arrangement.Do not assume any one outcome.MULTI-YEAR ANALYSISCompare:- actual results;- budgets;- forecasts;- prior periods;- subsequent periods where legitimately relevant;- product segments;- customer segments;- sales channels;- other group distributors;- relevant local market evidence.UK REVIEWWhere the United Kingdom is relevant, identify issues requiring consideration under the OECD Guidelines and current HMRC transfer pricing and business-reorganisation guidance.Do not state the current HMRC position from memory. Use official sources where authorised or mark CURRENT-HMRC-CHECK REQUIRED.OUTPUTProduce:1. Multi-year financial analysis.2. Quantified loss bridge.3. Risk-by-risk control analysis.4. Agreement-versus-conduct assessment.5. Independent-party options analysis.6. Evidence supporting the loss.7. Evidence undermining the position.8. Potential pricing or compensation scenarios.9. Strongest taxpayer argument.10. Strongest likely tax authority challenge.11. Recommended evidence-gathering plan.12. Draft factual defence narrative.For every conclusion distinguish:- fact;- inference;- assumption;- unresolved issue.Status: DRAFT — PROFESSIONAL JUDGEMENT AND LOCAL REVIEW REQUIRED.
Professional implementation guide
- Choose
- Copy
- Contextualise
- Challenge
- Verify
Limitations
DRAFT — PROFESSIONAL JUDGEMENT AND LOCAL REVIEW REQUIRED.
Version, origin and review
- Current version
- Version 1
- Origin
- AI-assisted
- Technical review status
- Not technically reviewed
- Published
- 17 Nov 2026
Contributors retain lawful intellectual property. Editorial review is not technical validation, and no prompt is certified.
Sources
No public source references supplied.